Suitable Process for Managing Innovation in a Changing External Environment


Innovation management in a changing external environment is crucial for maintaining competitiveness and ensuring long-term success. Different processes can be employed to manage innovation effectively, each with its strengths and suitability depending on the context and nature of the project. This paper examines four prominent innovation management processes: Stage-gate, Agile, Lean, and Discover-iterate-pivot. A brief description of each process is provided, followed by a recommendation on the most suitable process for managing innovation in a changing external environment.

Read also Creating a Culture of Innovation and Creativity – HMD Global

Stage-Gate Process for Managing Innovation


The Stage-gate process, developed by Dr. Robert G. Cooper, is a project management approach that divides a project into distinct stages separated by gates. Each stage involves a series of activities and deliverables, while gates serve as checkpoints where decisions are made about whether to proceed to the next stage.

Key Features

  1. Structured Approach: The process is highly structured, providing clear phases such as idea generation, scoping, business case development, development, testing, and launch.
  2. Decision Points: At each gate, a cross-functional team evaluates the progress against predefined criteria to decide if the project should continue, be modified, or be terminated.
  3. Risk Mitigation: It aims to reduce risk by ensuring that only projects meeting specific criteria proceed, thereby minimizing the chances of project failure.


The Stage-gate process is particularly suitable for projects with well-defined goals and longer timelines. It works well in environments where careful planning and adherence to strict guidelines are necessary, such as in industries with regulatory requirements.

Read also Four Reasons Why Entrepreneurial Organizations Seek Opportunities For Innovation

Agile Process for Managing Innovation


Agile is an iterative and incremental approach to project management and software development. It emphasizes flexibility, collaboration, and customer feedback. The Agile process breaks down projects into small, manageable segments known as sprints or iterations, which typically last between one to four weeks.

Key Features

  1. Iterative Development: Agile projects are divided into short cycles that allow for rapid development and continuous delivery of small, functional parts of the project.
  2. Customer Collaboration: Regular interaction with customers ensures that their feedback is integrated into the development process, leading to better alignment with customer needs.
  3. Flexibility: Agile is highly adaptable to changes in project scope or external environment, allowing teams to quickly respond to new information or shifting market conditions.


Agile is best suited for projects in dynamic environments where requirements may change frequently, such as software development. It is ideal for organizations that value speed, flexibility, and close collaboration with customers.

Read also Resolve Conflicts and Promote Collaboration as an Agile Coach

Lean Process for Managing Innovation


The Lean process focuses on maximizing value for the customer while minimizing waste. Originating from the manufacturing industry, Lean principles have been adapted for use in various sectors, including service and technology. The approach emphasizes efficiency and continuous improvement.

Key Features

  1. Value Stream Mapping: Identifying and analyzing the flow of materials and information to understand how value is delivered to the customer.
  2. Waste Reduction: Continuous identification and elimination of non-value-added activities to streamline processes and reduce costs.
  3. Continuous Improvement (Kaizen): Encouraging small, incremental improvements over time to enhance quality and efficiency.


Lean is highly effective in environments where efficiency and cost control are critical. It is particularly suitable for projects that require continuous improvement and where waste reduction can significantly impact the bottom line.

Discover-Iterate-Pivot Process for Managing Innovation


The Discover-iterate-pivot process is a flexible and adaptive approach often used in startups and innovation-driven projects. It emphasizes experimentation, learning, and the ability to pivot based on new insights.

Key Features

  1. Discovery Phase: Initial exploration of ideas through customer research, market analysis, and feasibility studies to identify viable opportunities.
  2. Iteration: Continuous testing and refinement of ideas through rapid prototyping and feedback loops to develop and improve products or solutions.
  3. Pivoting: The ability to change direction based on new insights or changes in the external environment to better meet market needs or exploit emerging opportunities.


This process is ideal for highly uncertain environments where the ability to experiment, learn quickly, and adapt is crucial. It is well-suited for innovation projects that require flexibility and rapid response to changing market conditions or technological advancements.


Assessing Suitability for Changing External Environments

In a changing external environment, the ability to adapt quickly and respond to new information is essential. The following criteria are crucial for selecting the most suitable innovation management process:

  1. Flexibility: The process should allow for rapid adjustments to project scope, priorities, and direction in response to external changes.
  2. Customer-Centric: Regular customer feedback and alignment with market needs are vital to ensure that the innovation remains relevant.
  3. Speed: The process should facilitate quick iterations and delivery of results to capitalize on emerging opportunities and stay ahead of competitors.

Read also Analysis of Strategies Related to Change and Innovation that Provide a Competitive Advantage

Recommended Process: Agile

Given the criteria above, the Agile process stands out as the most suitable for managing innovation in a changing external environment. Agile’s iterative nature, emphasis on customer collaboration, and flexibility make it ideal for adapting to shifting market dynamics and external changes.

  1. Flexibility: Agile allows teams to quickly pivot and make changes based on new insights or shifts in the external environment, ensuring that projects remain aligned with current market conditions.
  2. Customer-Centric: Regular interactions with customers provide continuous feedback, ensuring that the project stays relevant and meets customer needs effectively.
  3. Speed: The short iterations and rapid delivery cycles enable organizations to respond quickly to opportunities and challenges, maintaining a competitive edge.


In conclusion, while each innovation management process has its strengths, the Agile process is particularly well-suited for navigating a changing external environment. Its flexibility, customer-centric approach, and speed of delivery make it an ideal choice for organizations seeking to innovate and remain competitive in dynamic markets. By adopting Agile, organizations can better manage uncertainty, adapt to change, and deliver value effectively in an ever-evolving landscape.

Get Your Custom Paper From Professional Writers. 100% Plagiarism Free, No AI Generated Content and Good Grade Guarantee. We Have Experts In All Subjects.

Place Your Order Now
Scroll to Top